I don't mean to be rude, but I'd put my money on the guildie not being completely honest and/or not tracking party points. Screenshots would help prove it, but considering the apparent randomness, such a thing would be near impossible to get.
Also, if this bug is repeatable, chances are many people would have found it and exploited it a long time ago due to the age of the game, and then been fixed. See if your guildie can post here and give us a more detailed explanation of what happened (e.g. exactly how many tonics were returned, what disconnection error #, etc.)
|